Wisconsin jury instructions

Nov 2, 2021 · I don’t blame Chirafisi for making this argument, and the specific and somewhat ambiguous wording of the Wisconsin jury instruction on reckless endangerment surely gives the argument some legs. The normal practice, however, is to analyze the two victims separately—and, it must be admitted, there are circumstances in which self …

In addition to the State Law Library website, Wisconsin attorneys can also access the Wisconsin Jury Instructions via Fastcase through the State Bar of Wisconsin. Previously, a separate subscription was required, but going forward, the Jury Instructions will be included in Fastcase as a benefit to all State Bar members.Wisconsin Act 16, effective date: September 1, 2001. The offense is a Class I felony if the property damaged is a coin or card operated machine damaged in the course of a theft. See Wis JI-Criminal 1400A. The offense is a Class H felony if the property damaged is owned, leased, or operated by an energy provider [sub. (2k)]. See Wis JI-Criminal ...(1931). The Wisconsin Supreme Court discussed Osborne v. Montgomery in a 2015 decision, Dakter v. Cavallino, 2015 WI 67, 363 Wis.2d 738, 866 N.W.2d 656. In Dakter v. Cavallino, supra, the court reviewed a jury instruction in a case involving a collision between a passenger car and a semi -trailer truck. The negligenceWisconsin Jury Instructions serve as models, checklists or minimum standards to assist judges and lawyers in providing instructions to jurors who must …The jury should be able to give the phrase a common sense meaning in determining whether the conduct is such that it amounts to aggravated reckless homicide offense. A phrase with essentially the same meaning is used in the Model Penal Code. Section 2.02(1)(b)In the United States, citizens can be called to serve on jury duty as a way to participate in the country’s judicial process. If you get a summons in the mail, you’ll probably have many questions about the process that awaits you.This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions, volume 1.. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Civil 1413 (2006) The Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.

The Alexa Echo Instruction Manual is a comprehensive guide that helps users navigate and utilize all the features and functions of their Alexa Echo device. Whether you are a new owner or have had your device for a while, this manual serves ...that drafted Wisconsin’s Criminal Code, his interpretation of the Code was given great weight. Other members of the Criminal Jury Instructions Committee in 1971 had also been members of the Criminal Code Advisory Committee, making it likely that the instruction would have accurately reflected the intent of the legislature. Dec 23, 2020 · approved by the Committee in March 2015; it revised footnote 3 to reflect 2013 Wisconsin Act 307. This instruction is for a violation of§ 941.30(2), created by 1987 Wisconsin Act 399 as part of the revision of the homicide statutes. The amended statute applies to offenses committed on or after January 1, 1989.Jan 26, 2021 · All three Jury Instructions committees of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference will continue their standard schedules to develop instructions. New instructions will be published online. The Office of Judicial Education will continue to provide update releases indicating revised or new jury instructions for each set.948.03 (2) (b) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 3. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 2109 (2009) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.

Since 2021, Wisconsin’s jury instructions are available free from the Wisconsin State Law Library’s website at wilawlibrary.gov/jury. The online jury …343.44 (1) (b) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 3. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 2621 (2018) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.Wisconsin jury instructions can now be found for free online. The Office of Judicial Education, in partnership with the Wisconsin State Law Library, is providing free …968.075 (5) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 3. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 2044 (2013) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions, volume 2. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Civil 1900.4 (2022) The Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference. Instructions include contributions ...That means the Law Library is home to the Jury Instructions in print in several locations. The Jury Instructions are broken down into three different parts: Civil, Criminal and Children. Each part will be shelved very closely together if not right next to each other, so if you find one, then you have probably found them all!

Raleigh durham chapel hill craigslist.

Nestled in the heart of Wisconsin Dells, the Mount Olympus Hotel is a magical destination for families and couples alike. With its stunning views of the Wisconsin River, luxurious amenities, and family-friendly activities, this hotel is sur...Wisconsin's Door County is known as the "Cape Cod of the Midwest" for good reason. Here's what to do, where to eat, and where to stay. Only about 30,000 people live in Door County Wisconsin, yet more than two million visitors a year typical...The uniform jury instructions "serve as models, checklists or minimum standards to assist judges and lawyers in providing instructions to jurors who must reach verdicts during trials," according to a Jan. 25 media release from the Wisconsin Court System announcing online access.Dec 23, 2020 · This instruction is for a violation of § 941.30(1), as amended by 1987 Wisconsin Act 399 as part of the revision of the homicide statutes. The amended statute applies to offenses committed on or after January 1, 1989. For a brief overview of the homicide revision, see the Introductory Comment at Wis JI-Criminal 1000.

The Milwaukee County Law Library is open Monday through Friday with varying hours. To ask a question, call us at 608-267-9696 or Ask a Librarian online. Find contact information and learn more about services and hours from our three libraries on our library locations page. proof” be included among those provided to the jury in writing. Compare E. B. v. State, 111 Wis.2d 175, 330 N.W.2d 584 (1983), where the Wisconsin Supreme Court held that Wis JI-Criminal 140 was not one of the “substantive” instructions that were to be provided to the jury in writing under the former version of § 972.10(5).This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions, volume 1.. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Civil 1413 (2006) The Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.Professor Schultz has been the Reporter for the Wisconsin Jury Instructions-Criminal since 1976. He has published a book review on Escape of the Guilty in the Marquette Law Review (1987) and, earlier, co-authored with UW Law Professors Remington and Dickey an article titled "Law, Trial Judges, and the Psychiatric Witness," which appeared in the ...Operating a Motor Vehicle While Under the Influence of an Intoxicant - Criminal Offense. Last revised in 2020. Download this jury instruction. Word PDF. Related Statutes: 346.63 (1) (a) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 4. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 2663 (2020) 948.03 (2) (b) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 3. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 2109 (2009) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.Dec 23, 2020 · 1953 Judiciary Committee Report on the Criminal Code, Wisconsin Legislative Council, page 58. 4. See § 939.23(4) and Wis JI-Criminal 923A and 923B. 5. If definition of "without consent" is believed to be necessary, see Wis JI-Criminal 948 which provides an instruction based on the definition provided in § 939.22(48). That definition …Apr 28, 2022 · Match case Limit results 1 per page. CD o CD JJ » (fJ I e Schultz Marks 30 Years with Jury Instructions Committee Editor's Note: 1his on-the-scene view of UW Law School Professor David Schultz's work with Wisconsin's Criminal Jury Instructions Committee is reprinted with permission from The Third Branch, a quarterly publication of …

941.30 (2) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 2A. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 1347 (2015) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference. Instructions ...

The Office of Judicial Education will continue to provide update releases indicating revised or new jury instructions for each set. The Wisconsin Jury Instructions (Civil, Criminal, and Children’s) are now freely available online on the Wisconsin State Law Library website.961.41 (3g) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 4. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 6030 (2021) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.The Wisconsin Jury Instructions are created as models, checklists, or minimum standards. It may be necessary to modify instructions to accommodate the facts of the case. There is not a model instruction for every cause of action, criminal offense, or other situation. Related Statutes: 943.10 (1) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 2A. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 1421 (2020) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.Nov 18, 2021 · Wisconsin’s law of self-defense and its jury instruction on provocation should more clearly indicate that an individual who provokes or instigates the conflict forfeits the right of self-defense.Nov 2, 2021 · I don’t blame Chirafisi for making this argument, and the specific and somewhat ambiguous wording of the Wisconsin jury instruction on reckless endangerment surely gives the argument some legs. The normal practice, however, is to analyze the two victims separately—and, it must be admitted, there are circumstances in which self …343.44 (1) (b) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 3. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 2621 (2018) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.• Wisconsin Jury Instructions—Criminal, 2019 Edition including Release 57 (Wis JI-Criminal), 5-Volume looseleaf binders, authored by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference. These Wisconsin Jury Instructions contain “over one thousand jury instructions to assistWisconsin Jury Instructions (Civil, Criminal, & Children) are available in print at Marquette Law Library and online as explained below. Wisconsin State Law Library offers WI Jury Instructions online: https://wilawlibrary.gov/jury/ . Marquette Law Students also have access through the Fastcase link listed on the law library homepage.

Aa retirees travel login.

Slope minecraft.

The Wisconsin Court System protects individuals' rights, privileges and liberties, maintains the rule of law, and provides a forum for the resolution of disputes that is fair, accessible, independent and effective. Directories. All directories; Supreme Court/state administrative offices;940.19 (2) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 2. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 1222 (2017) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference.Chapter 161 was renumbered Chapter 961 by 1995 Wisconsin Act 448. Effective date: July 9, 1996. Act 448 also extended the coverage of controlled substance offenses to include “controlled substance analogs.” See Wis JI-Criminal 6005 and 6020A. 2011 Wisconsin Act 31 amended § 961.41(3g) by creating sub. (3g)(em) which prohibits possession of ...If you received a juror summons in the mail, some counties allow you to check if you need to report for jury duty online. Click here for more information . Postponement …Wisconsin jury instructions can now be found for free online. The Office of Judicial Education, in partnership with the Wisconsin State Law Library, is providing free …Pattern Criminal Federal Jury Instructions: 7th Circuit; Wisconsin Jury Instructions. Children; Civil; Criminal; Grand Juries . Handbook for Federal Grand …Without a license causing great bodily harm or death | 2612. Operating a commercial motor vehicle with an alcohol concentration of 0.04 grams or more but less than 0.08 grams - criminal offense | 2690. Operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of any combination of an intoxicant and any other drug | 2666A.It is the duty of the jury to scrutinize and to weigh the testimony of witnesses and to ... The supreme court has allowed the trial court considerable latitude in instructions dealing with the . 300 WIS JI-CRIMINAL 300 Wisconsin Court System, 1/2023 (Release No. 61) 3 credibility of witnesses. A few cases are illustrative. In Emery v.All three Jury Instructions committees of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference will continue their standard schedules to develop instructions. New instructions will be published online. The Office of Judicial Education will continue to provide update releases indicating revised or new jury instructions for each set.941.30 (1) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 2A. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 1345 (2020) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference. Instructions ... ….

Nestled in the heart of Wisconsin Dells, the Mount Olympus Hotel is a magical destination for families and couples alike. With its stunning views of the Wisconsin River, luxurious amenities, and family-friendly activities, this hotel is sur...Nov 20, 2021 · Kyle Rittenhouse listens as the attorneys and the judge talk about jury instructions at the Kenosha County Courthouse in Kenosha, Wis., on Monday, Nov. 15, 2021.Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 1226 (2022) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference. Instructions include contributions from the University of Wisconsin-Madison Law School, and are used with its permission.Id. at 505. use When faced with a divisible statute, courts a "modified categorical approach" and look "to a limited class of documents (for example, the indictment, jury instructions, or plea agreement and colloquy) to determine what crime, with what elements, a defendant was convicted of." Id. at 505-06.The Wisconsin Jury Instructions (Civil, Criminal, and Children's) are now freely available online on the Wisconsin State Law Library website. This is a result of a cooperative effort between the University of Wisconsin Law School, the State Law Library, and the Wisconsin Court System's Office of Judicial Education.Nov 20, 2021 · The defense rested its case Thursday, and lawyers and the judge were working in court Friday on what instructions to give to the jury. 8:41 p.m. ET, November 19, 2021 ... Wisconsin, was acquitted ...A jury duty exemption letter is a response to a jury summons that states a given reason why the potential juror is exempted from serving jury duty. Each state has specific exemptions pertaining to jury duty, and most of them require a lette...Nov 11, 2022 · Creators of an easy-to-access digital version of the official Wisconsin jury instructions, an online platform with free legal forms and information for neighborhood entrepreneurs, and a commercial document review system powered by artificial intelligence are among the recipients of the Wisconsin Lawyer Legal Innovator awards for 2022.. The …January 04, 2023 Legal Research 101: Wisconsin Jury Instructions Wisconsin has over 1,600 jury instructions, and all are now available online at no cost. Law librarian Carol Hassler discusses the basics of Wisconsin jury instructions, and how to stay on top of the latest updates. Carol HasslerThe Wisconsin Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Jury Instructions Committees of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference. The Wisconsin Jury Instructions include contributions from the University of Wisconsin-Madison Law School, and are used with its permission. Wisconsin jury instructions, The rules for jury trials come from the law, tradition, and experience. In summary, the steps are as follows: Jurors are sworn to answer truthfully all questions about their qualifications for the case., All three Jury Instructions committees of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference will continue their standard schedules to develop instructions. New instructions will be published online. The Office of Judicial Education will continue to provide update releases indicating revised or new jury instructions for each set., 301.45. This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 3. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 2198 (2021) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference., 940.05. This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 2. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 1014 (2021) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference., Without a license causing great bodily harm or death | 2612. Operating a commercial motor vehicle with an alcohol concentration of 0.04 grams or more but less than 0.08 grams - criminal offense | 2690. Operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of any combination of an intoxicant and any other drug | 2666A., Nov 1, 2021 · Kyle Rittenhouse will argue self-defense. Experts say proving the argument to a jury isn't easy. MILWAUKEE — Within hours of the shootings in Kenosha, Wisconsin, last year, supporters were ..., Wisconsin law establishes a low bar that the accused must surmount to be entitled to a jury instruction on the privilege of self-defense. The accused need produce only “some evidence" in support of the privilege of self-defense. State v. Stietz, 2017 WI 58, 369 Wis. 2d 222, 880 N.W.2d 182, 14-2701., 940.203 (2) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 2. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 1240D (2019) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference. Instructions ..., Jan 26, 2021 · Wisconsin Jury Instructions Online. We're happy to announce that the Wisconsin State Law Library is now hosting current Wisconsin Jury Instructions on our website. https://wilawlibrary.gov/jury/. This is a result of a cooperative effort between the University of Wisconsin Law School, the State Law Library, and the Wisconsin Court …, Wisconsin's Door County is known as the "Cape Cod of the Midwest" for good reason. Here's what to do, where to eat, and where to stay. Only about 30,000 people live in Door County Wisconsin, yet more than two million visitors a year typical..., January 04, 2023 Legal Research 101: Wisconsin Jury Instructions Wisconsin has over 1,600 jury instructions, and all are now available online at no cost. Law librarian Carol Hassler discusses the basics of Wisconsin jury instructions, and how to stay on top of the latest updates. Carol Hassler, (1931). The Wisconsin Supreme Court discussed Osborne v. Montgomery in a 2015 decision, Dakter v. Cavallino, 2015 WI 67, 363 Wis.2d 738, 866 N.W.2d 656. In Dakter v. Cavallino, supra, the court reviewed a jury instruction in a case involving a collision between a passenger car and a semi -trailer truck. The negligence, Longstanding Wisconsin case law has interpreted this offense and the reference to sec. 943.20 as not simply a reference to the penalty provision but rather to the definition of theft by trustee under sec. 943.20(1)(b), thereby incorporating the elements of that offense. Pauly v. Keebler, 175 Wis. 428, 185 N.W.2d 554 (1921); State v. , 943.23 (2) 943.23 (3) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 2A. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 1464A (2019) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference., has shown and try to persuade the jury (closing statements or arguments). BOTH SIDES PRESENT THEIR CASE 4. The judge instructs the jury on the law that applies to the case. Jury Deliberation 1. The jury selects a foreperson. 2. The evidence and instructions are discussed and the jurors try to reach agreement. 3. The verdict is agreed upon. 4., 349 Wis.2d 587, 836 N.W.2d 807. This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions, volume 2. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Civil 2418 (2021) The Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference., 301.45. This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 3. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 2198 (2021) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference., Jun 2, 2021 · There are over 1,500 civil, criminal, and juvenile Wisconsin Jury Instructions available to researchers. Current jury instructions are available for free browsing and download from the Wisconsin State Law Library website. As mentioned above, Fastcase is free to all Wisconsin-licensed attorneys through their State Bar memberships. Fastcase ..., Legal Advisor – Jury Instructions Reporter, Wisconsin Civil Jury Instructions Committee SUBJECT: 2021 Supplement to Wisconsin Jury Instructions – Civil The enclosed 2021 supplement to Wisconsin Jury Instructions – Civil was recently approved by the Wisconsin Judicial Conference’s Civil Jury Instructions Committee. It is the fifty-, Without a license causing great bodily harm or death | 2612. Operating a commercial motor vehicle with an alcohol concentration of 0.04 grams or more but less than 0.08 grams - criminal offense | 2690. Operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of any combination of an intoxicant and any other drug | 2666A. , appeals held that when a bail jumping charge is based on the commission of a new crime, the jury must be instructed on the elements of that crime. See the text of the instruction at footnote 12. The statute is also violated by one who has been released from custody under Chapter 969 and commits a crime in another jurisdiction. State v., For details on the jury system and failure to appear policies in your county follow the links on the county circuit court contacts page. Special assistance. It is the policy of the Wisconsin Court System that its programs, …, 946.41. This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 2A. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 1766 (2010) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference. , This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 1.. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 180 (2021) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference., that drafted Wisconsin’s Criminal Code, his interpretation of the Code was given great weight. Other members of the Criminal Jury Instructions Committee in 1971 had also been members of the Criminal Code Advisory Committee, making it likely that the instruction would have accurately reflected the intent of the legislature., 343.44 (1) (b) This instruction is also found in the print edition of the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions, volume 3. Cite this instruction as: Wis. JI—Criminal 2621 (2018) The Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions are created and edited by the Wisconsin Criminal Jury Instructions Committee of the Wisconsin Judicial Conference., Jury instructions are the only guidance the jury should receive when deliberating and are meant to keep the jury on track regarding the basic procedure of the ..., In the United States, citizens can be called to serve on jury duty as a way to participate in the country’s judicial process. If you get a summons in the mail, you’ll probably have many questions about the process that awaits you., (1931). The Wisconsin Supreme Court discussed Osborne v. Montgomery in a 2015 decision, Dakter v. Cavallino, 2015 WI 67, 363 Wis.2d 738, 866 N.W.2d 656. In Dakter v. Cavallino, supra, the court reviewed a jury instruction in a case involving a collision between a passenger car and a semi -trailer truck. The negligence, Wisconsin Jury Instructions serve as models, checklists or minimum standards to assist judges and lawyers in providing instructions to jurors who must reach verdicts during trials., Employers are required to grant an employee a leave of absence for jury service per Wisconsin Statute §756.255. As soon as a juror receives a summons for jury ..., Fastcase, a legal research database, is the only place to find the Wisconsin Jury Instructions digitally at this link: http://digital.library.wisc.edu/1711.web/Wisconsin …, on jury agreement. See Wis JI-Criminal 517 JURY AGREEMENT: EVIDENCE OF MORE THAN ONE ACT INTRODUCED TO PROVE ONE CHARGE. 4. Section 346.04(3) reads “willful or wanton (emphasis added). The Committee omitted ” or “ wanton,” concluding that the phrase does not add anything substantial to the offense. If it appears that “or